Genetic Genealogy: How AI is Enhancing DNA Analysis

April Challenge: A to Z AI in Genealogy

Confession:

I do not have first-hand knowledge of Genetic Genealogy or the evolution of DNA Analysis. To help with my learning curve on these topics I viewed this webinar from one of my favourite Genealogical Crime Mystery authors, Nathan Dylan Goodwin. The webinar, The Science Behind the Stories: Using Genetic Genealogy in Crime Fiction, was part of the recent 24-hour marathon from Legacy Webinars, and is free for viewing until April 11. Nathan explained the process of Investigative Genetic Genealogy (IGG) and how it can be and is being used to solve crimes. He explored the process used by his fictitious IGG team in the books in the Venator Cold Case series.

I was so impressed with how Nathan helped me build my knowledge of IGG in this video, that I now aim to read the latest book in the series, The Hollywood Strangler (Venator Cold Case #3). Now, I need to learn more about Genetic Genealogy.

Personal Learning Strategy:

My next step was to investigate the tutorials on DNA 101: An Insider's Scoop on AncestryDNA Testing at the Ancestry Academy. Plenty of learning opportunities here in short byte-sized videos taking me from novice to knowledgeable status.

But, where does AI fit in the picture? I needed to ‘level-up’ on this topic, so I asked my AI assistant, Claude Sonnet 3.7, to help with this learning by creating the content for this post.

Claude’s response is displayed below! I have made minimal changes to the content as I did not feel confident to do so. So if you see something that does not sound right, please let me know.

Genetic Genealogy with AI

Genetic genealogy has transformed family history research over the past two decades. What began with simple Y-DNA and mitochondrial DNA tests has evolved into comprehensive autosomal DNA analysis that can connect us with cousins across multiple family lines. Now, artificial intelligence is taking DNA analysis to new heights, helping genealogists break through longstanding brick walls and discover connections that were previously impossible to detect.

Key AI Advancements in Genetic Genealogy

Pattern Recognition in Match Lists

Traditional DNA match analysis requires a painstaking comparison of shared matches, segment data, and family trees. AI now streamlines this process by:

• Identifying clusters of matches likely connected through specific ancestral lines

• Detecting patterns in shared DNA segments that suggest particular relationships

• Flagging potential errors in user-created family trees based on genetic evidence

• Predicting relationships with greater accuracy by analyzing multiple data points simultaneously

This pattern recognition capability helps genealogists focus their research efforts on the most promising connections.

Biogeographical Analysis Enhancement

Ethnicity estimates have been popular but often frustratingly imprecise. AI is improving these estimates through:

• More sophisticated reference population modeling

• Better detection of small percentages of ancestry

• More precise geographic pinpointing of genetic signatures

• Improved differentiation between closely related populations

These improvements help genealogists better understand ancestral origins, particularly for lines with limited paper documentation.

Note: I now have a better understanding of the biogeographical analysis diagrams that people share in TV programs such as DNA Family Secrets from the BBC.

Triangulation Automation

Triangulation—comparing DNA segments shared between three or more people—has traditionally required manual spreadsheet work. AI now:

• Automatically identifies triangulated groups across match lists

• Calculates the statistical significance of shared segments

• Suggests the most likely common ancestor based on multiple data points

• Identifies which matches would be most valuable to contact based on unique shared segments

This automation saves countless hours while improving analytical accuracy.

Note: Triangulation was a new term to me in this field. Along with several other specialist terms such as centimorgans, clusters, and phenotype. I asked Perplexity for more information. Here is a shared Page on Triangulation Automation.

Phenotype Prediction and Historical Insights

Beyond relationship connections, AI is offering new insights into how our ancestors may have appeared:

• Predicting physical traits like hair color, eye color, and facial features from DNA

• Identifying genetic health factors that may have influenced ancestral lives

• Correlating genetic signatures with historical migration patterns

• Reconstructing likely physical characteristics of distant ancestors

These capabilities help bring ancestral stories to life in new ways.

Note: Nathan describes these as EVCs - externally visible characteristics.

Practical Applications for Genealogists

Solving Unknown Parentage Cases

For adoptees and others with unknown parentage, AI tools now:

• Predict relationships between matches with greater precision

• Identify the most likely ancestral lines to research based on genetic clustering

• Suggest specific research strategies based on match patterns

• Estimate degrees of relationship with significantly improved accuracy

These capabilities have revolutionized unknown parentage research, making solutions possible in days or weeks rather than years.

Note: Nathan mentions that this can be done using the adoptee’s DNA only.

Investigative Genetic Genealogy

Investigative genetic genealogy—using DNA databases to solve crimes and identify unknown deceased individuals—has been transformed by AI capabilities. Law enforcement agencies and forensic genealogists now employ sophisticated AI tools to:

• Analyze DNA samples from crime scenes against public genetic databases

• Reconstruct possible family trees from distant genetic matches

• Identify common ancestors and descendant lines with remarkable precision

• Narrow suspect pools through genetic trait prediction and geographical analysis

AI significantly accelerates this process by automating complex genetic comparisons and identifying the most promising family connections to investigate. While this application raises important ethical questions about privacy and consent, it has successfully resolved hundreds of cold cases and brought closure to families of unidentified deceased individuals. The same AI techniques that help adoptees find biological families are now helping to bring justice and resolution in previously unsolvable cases.

Note: Nathan mentions the use of ‘background check websites’ eg. BeenVerified. I investigated that one and found that it is restricted to America.

Breaking Through Brick Walls

For longstanding genealogical mysteries, AI analysis of DNA data can:

• Identify previously overlooked connection patterns in match lists

• Suggest specific documentary evidence to seek based on genetic clustering

• Differentiate between multiple theories using probability analysis

• Combine genetic evidence with documentary evidence to support conclusions

Many genealogists report solving decades-old research problems through AI-enhanced DNA analysis.

Note: Nathan mentions the use of IGG in such famous ‘cold cases’ as: The Golden State Killer case in which Joseph DeAngelo was convicted after 40 years. IGG triaging helped in the final investigation.

Validating Paper Trails

Even for well-documented family lines, AI-powered DNA analysis provides:

• Confirmation of documented relationships through genetic pattern matching

• Identification of potential errors in traditional research

• Evidence for choosing between conflicting documentary sources

• Validation of connections where records are sparse or missing

This validation adds a crucial layer of evidence to traditional research.

Challenges and Considerations

Privacy and Consent

As AI analyzes genetic data with increasing sophistication, important questions arise about:

• Appropriate use of DNA data from matches who haven't opted into advanced analysis

• Potential for revealing sensitive information through advanced predictive algorithms

• Long-term implications of having genetic data in commercial databases

• Balancing research benefits against privacy considerations

Responsible genealogists must consider these ethical dimensions carefully.

Note: I have been following the news reports on the ‘23andMe Bankruptcy’ case and this story 23andMe is on the verge of bankruptcy. It may be too late to delete your genetic data from the ABC Newsroom; gave me pause for thought.

Interpretive Limitations

Despite impressive capabilities, AI analysis of genetic data has limitations:

• Results remain probabilistic rather than definitively conclusive

• Reference populations continue to have gaps, particularly for underrepresented groups

• DNA alone cannot tell the full story of ancestral lives and relationships

• Human judgment remains essential for evaluating AI-generated suggestions

Understanding these limitations helps prevent overreliance on technology.

Note: Further investigation into the various facets surrounding this topic can be accessed from Cyndi’s List for DNA.

Integration with Traditional Research

The most successful approach integrates AI-powered DNA analysis with traditional genealogical methods by:

• Using AI suggestions as hypotheses to verify through documentary research

• Applying the Genealogical Proof Standard to conclusions derived from genetic evidence

• Combining multiple types of evidence to build stronger cases

• Recognizing when DNA evidence should take precedence over ambiguous records

This integrated approach leverages the strengths of both traditional and genetic genealogy.

Note: Further learning was gained by watching the Dana Leeds Method videos on her YouTube Channel. How to Do the Leeds Method with Your DNA Matches: A Step-by-Step Guide and How to Sort Your DNA Matches with AI and the Leeds Method

The Future of AI in Genetic Genealogy

Looking ahead, we can anticipate several exciting developments:

• Integrated Analysis Platforms: Systems that simultaneously analyze DNA data alongside documentary evidence

• Expanded Reference Populations: Better representation of historically underrepresented groups

• Temporal Analysis: Better understanding of how genetic signatures changed over time in specific regions

• Advanced Visualization Tools: More intuitive ways to understand complex genetic relationships

These advancements will continue to expand the genealogical problems we can solve through genetic analysis.

Getting Started with AI-Enhanced DNA Analysis

If you're new to genetic genealogy or looking to incorporate AI tools into your existing practice:

1. Test with major companies that offer ongoing algorithm improvements (AncestryDNA, 23andMe, FamilyTreeDNA, MyHeritage)

2. Upload your raw data to third-party sites that offer AI-powered analysis tools

3. Start with simple clustering tools before advancing to more complex analysis

4. Join genetic genealogy communities to learn from others' experiences

5. Maintain realistic expectations about what genetic evidence can and cannot tell you

Remember that AI tools are most effective when combined with sound genealogical methodology and critical thinking.

Note: My learning journey has clarified the purpose, the method, and the process used in DNA matching, but it has not convinced me of the ethics and safety issues of ‘doing one’s DNA’!

Summary

AI is transforming genetic genealogy from a specialized technical field into an accessible and powerful tool for family historians at all levels. By automating complex analyses, identifying subtle patterns, and generating insights from massive datasets, AI helps us extract maximum value from our genetic connections.

The key to success lies in understanding both the capabilities and limitations of these technologies—approaching them not as magical solutions but as sophisticated tools that extend our research capabilities. When combined with traditional research methods and sound genealogical reasoning, AI-enhanced genetic genealogy offers unprecedented opportunities to discover and validate family connections across time and space.

Learning about Genetic Genealogy can be enhanced by reading ‘novels’ in which the author has included details of the IGG process and outcomes for solving murder mysteries. I highly recommend reading the Venator Cold Case Series from Nathan Dylan Goodwin.

Note: Nathan suggests that you start with #1 The Chester Creek Murders

---

Ready to elevate your genealogy research with AI? Come and learn how to become an AI-skilled ancestral storyteller in the course, "Beyond the Pen: Using AI to Transform Ancestral Storytelling." Discover practical techniques and ethical approaches to incorporating AI into your family history work. Join us at Beyond the Pen and transform how you preserve your family's legacy!